Fame is fickle, especially inreality TV, where stardom can vanish as quickly as it arrives. Many reality stars, once fixtures of our screens and social media feeds, have disappeared from the spotlight with no explanation. TakeJon Gosselin, whose familyshowJon & Kate Plus 8drew millions of viewers before his messy divorce and departure from reality TV.SurvivorlegendRichard Hatchis another example. His win in 2000 made him a TV pioneer — only for legal troubles to overshadow his fame years later. These stars once made headlines but have since retreated into quieter, more private lives.
For those wondering, the reasons behind these departures are varied and often complex. Some, likeHeidi Montag ofThe Hills, willingly stepped away after public backlash and personal struggles. Others, likeAmerican IdolstarNikki Mckibbin, faced tragic circumstances. After herrise to fame onAmerican Idol, Mckibbin struggled with addiction and later died in 2020 from a brain aneurysm. All in all, the disappearance of reality stars from the spotlight is more common than fans think, especially when the intense scrutiny of fame proves to be overwhelming.
1Brooke Hogan
‘Hogan Knows Best’
Brooke Hogan, daughter offamed wrestlerHulk Hogan, once seemed perfect for a lasting career in reality TV. She gained fame in the mid-2000s through the VH1 programHogan Knows Best—a reality show focused onher famous family. Brooke Hogan’s foray into music with a hit single, “About Us,” in 2006 added to her fame. She also received her own spin-off series,Brooke Knows Best, in 2008, but her career never quite soared with that. Despite a promising start in music and reality TV, she gradually faded from mainstream media.
Several professional and personal challenges contributed to Brooke’s retreat. Her family became ferociously embroiled in some public scandals.Hulk Hogan’s infamous lawsuit against Gawkerand his firing from WWE over racist commentsare some of them. Brooke found herself defending her father on social media, and all of this took a toll on her public image. In 2013,TMZreported thatBrooke Hogan broke off her engagementwith NFL playerPhil Costa. Though she dabbled in other projects, including hosting Amazon’sThe Fashion Hero in 2017, things never changed. Hogan has since shifted her focus to more private ventures and making sporadic media appearances but largely staying out of the spotlight.
Hogan Knows Best
2Clay Aiken
‘American Idol’ Season 2
Clay Aikenskyrocketed to fame as the runner-up ofSeason 2 ofAmerican Idolin 2003, narrowly losing toRuben Studdardin a controversial finale. Despite not winning, the fans loved Aiken’s strong voice and geek-to-chic transformation, which led to a successful music career. His debut albumMeasure of a Manwent multi-platinum, and he became a household name with hits like “Invisible” and “This is the Night.” But Aiken gradually shifted away from the entertainment world after aBroadway stint inSpamalotand a few more music albums.
In recent years, Aiken has pursued a different path — politics. He was an ambassador of UNICEF from 2004 to 2013.In 2014, Aiken ran for Congress. Although unsuccessful, he tried again in 2022, with the hope of becoming North Carolina’s openly gay representative. His focus shifted from the stage to advocating for healthcare reform, gun control, and voting rights. While his days of pop stardom have taken a backseat, his activities and public service remain at the front.
American Idol
WATCH ON FUBO
3Danity Kane
‘Making the Band 3’
This girl groupcreated onMaking the Band 3rose to fame in the mid-2000sunder Diddy’s Bad Boy Records. Initially, the group’s five members —Aubrey O’Day,Dawn Richard,Shannon Bex,Aundrea Fimbres, andD. Woods— found commercial success with hits like “Show Stopper” and “Damaged.” Later on, internal conflicts and management issues plagued the group. In 2008,Diddy controversially dismissed Aubrey O’Day, and by 2009, the group officially disbanded. This marked the beginning of their disappearance from mainstream media.
After the band’s separation, Danity Kane has attempted several comebacks, including a brief reunion in 2013. Unfortunately, all these efforts were overshadowed by personal drama.TMZ reported in 2014 thatO’Day and Richard had a physical altercationin the studio which led to another breakup. Despite their troubled history, three of the original members — O’Day, Bex, and Richard — reunited again in 2018 for a tour. While they’ve occasionally returned to the stage, the constant friction and inconsistent management led to their quiet retreat from the spotlight.
Making the Band 3is not currently available to stream in the US.
4Spencer Pratt
‘The Hills’
Spencer Pratt, once known as reality TV’sultimate villain fromThe Hills, saw great fame during the show’s run between 2006 and 2010. Pratt and his wife, Heidi Montag, became infamous for their over-the-top drama and constant presence in the tabloids. However, followingThe Hills’sconclusion, the couple quickly faded from the spotlight as their lavish lifestyle led them to financial troubles. Despite their on-screen success, Pratt toldPEOPLEexclusively thathe felt “alone and defeated”after losing millions of dollars.
In an attempt to revive their fame, Pratt and Montag made appearances onvarious reality TV showslikeCelebrity Big Brother UKandMarriage Boot Camp. In 2017, Pratt gained unexpected attention on Snapchat, where his obsession with hummingbirds garnered a loyal following. Yet, even that popularity proved fleeting, as it never quite propelled him back into the mainstream. The 2019 reboot ofThe Hills: New Beginningsgave Pratt and Montag another shot at reality TV drama. However, the show was canceled after two seasons.
5The Gotti Kids
‘Growing Up Gotti’
The Gotti Kids —John,Carmine, andFrankie Gotti Agnello— became well-known through the hit A&E reality showGrowing Up Gotti, which aired from 2004 to 2005. The show followed the sons ofVictoria Gotti, the daughter of infamous mob bossJohn Gotti, and exhibited their lavish lives. Soon, the Gotti boys became reality TV sensations with their flashy hairstyles, designer clothes, and larger-than-life personalities. After the show ended, all three brothers slowly withdrew from the public eye.
John Gotti Agnello, the eldest, shifted his focus to running auto body shops in Queens and started a family.Carmine Gotti Agnelloattempted to break into the music industry and released a few singles that never climbed the popularity charts. He pleaded guilty to wire fraud in September 2024 andnow faces 30 years in prison, according toThe NY Times.Frank Gottie Agnello, the youngest, authoredThe Gotti Dietto document his weight-loss journey. After the book’s release, he, too, stepped away from public life to help with the family business. All three brothers now focus on their family legacy and work in various ventures while maintaining a lower profile than in their reality TV days.
Growing Up Gotti
6Tila Tequila
‘A Shot at Love With Tila Tequila’
Tila Tequilawas once a famous TV star,thanks to her MTVreality showA Shot at Love With Tila Tequila. Rising to fame in the early 2000s as thequeen of MySpace due to her massive social media following, Tila Tequila leveraged this popularity to launch her reality TV career. The bisexual-themed dating show, whereboth men and women vied for her affection, was a controversial hit at the time and ran for two seasons. This show propelled her into pop culture stardom, but as soon as the show ended, Tequila’s life took a dark turn.
In the years following her reality TV success,Tila Tequila’s public personashifted drastically as she became involved in various controversies. She was banned fromCelebrity Big Brotherin 2015 after her extreme, far-right political views — including Nazi sympathies — came to light. Tila Tequila’s erratic behavior severely damaged her public image and led to her being largely blacklisted by mainstream media. These days, Tila Tequila has embraced a different part as a born-again Christian. Despite her fame, her controversial actions and extreme views caused her to disappear from the entertainment industry almost entirely.
A Shot at Love with Tila Tequila
WATCH ON PRIME
7Kate Gosselin
‘Jon & Kate Plus 8’
Kate Gosselinrose to reality TV fame withJon & Kate Plus 8, a show that revolved around her life with her then-husbandJon Gosselinand their eight children. The show premiered in 2007 and became a massive hit on TLC because it offered a peek into the chaotic dynamics of raising sextuplets and twins.However, after her divorce in 2009, Kate Gosselin’s fame took a nosedive.While she tried to stay in the spotlight with projects likeKate Plus 8and even the dating showKate Plus Date, these attempts were short-lived. Her 2019 dating show was canceled after only six episodes due to poor ratings.
Since then, she has retreated from reality TV.In 2021,Kate Gosselin sold her Pennsylvania homefor $1.085 million and relocated to North Carolina, where she got a nursing license. She has mostly remained out of the spotlight and avoided media attention as her children have grown into young adults.Despite the Gosselin family’s ongoing struggles— particularly with her son,Collin Gosselin, who moved in with Jon Gosselin after claiming he was sent to an institution against his will — Kate Gosselin seems content with her quieter lifestyle.
Jon & Kate Plus 8
WATCH ON MAX
8Lo Bosworth
‘Laguna Beach’ and ‘The Hills’
Lo Bosworthwas a well-known star onMTV’s hit reality showsLaguna BeachandThe Hillsin the 2000s, but she decided to bid farewell to her life as a reality TV actress. After years of reality TV fame,Lo realized that the lifestyle wasn’t for her.Though she appreciated the opportunities it provided, the constant public scrutiny was too much for her. While opening up toHollywood Lifeexclusively, she said,“Working in television was not my strong suit.“She also admitted that she wanted a normal life, which led her to step away from reality TV afterThe Hillsconcluded in 2010.
Since then, Bosworth has focused on building a successful career outside entertainment.In 2016, she founded Love Wellness,a women’s wellness brand that offers personal care products topromote physical and mental health.Bosworth has been candid about her passion for this industry. She views this as a healthier, more fulfilling space than reality TV’s drama-filled world. She has also published a book,Love Yourself Well, and attended culinary school to further distance herself from her reality TV persona.
Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County
WATCH ON PARAMOUNT+
9Stacy London
‘What Not to Wear’
Stacy Londonco-hostedWhat Not to Wearin the early 2000s. She helped peopletransform their wardrobesand confidence through the show. However, after the show ended in 2013, London’s public appearances dwindled and left the fans wondering where she went. In reality, London faced significantpersonal and professional challengesduring that time. She informed everyone about an upcoming spinal surgery in December 2016 throughan essay for Refinery29. She also posted a photo of the titanium screws in her back on Instagramto let the fans in on her struggle. Besides, she openly admitted that the recovery caused major financial and mental setbacks for her.
In recent years, London has shifted her focus away from television and towards the wellness of older women.
In recent years, London has shifted her focus away from television and towards the wellness of older women. In 2024, she launched a fashion line with QVC aimed at women over 50, which reflects her passion for empowering people through style as they age. London has also been anadvocate for raising awareness about menopause. This new chapter of her career shows how she managed to use her expertise to help others feel good about themselves — both inside and out. Though no longer a TV regular, Stacy London has re-emerged with a new purpose.
WATCH ON APPLE TV+
10Adrianne Curry
‘America’s Next Top Model’
Adrianne Curry is the first-everwinner ofAmerica’s Next Top Model. She seemed destined for supermodel fame, but her journey took some unexpected turns. After her 2003 victory, Curry believed she was on the brink of high-fashion success and was expecting major modeling contracts. However, she later toldPEOPLEthatthese promises were misleading, andmuch of what was showcased on the show didn’t materialize. Feeling betrayed by the industry’s harsh realities,Curry described the modeling world as “cutthroat” and “predatory.”
Following her modeling stint, Curry ventured into reality TV.She starred inTheSurreal Lifeand later inMy Fair Bradywhich her relationship withThe Brady BunchstarChristopher Knight.By 32, she left Hollywood behind, particularly after being offered a job in exchange for getting face fillers. This offer made her reevaluate her career path. She felt that the pressure to alter her appearance with cosmetic surgeries was a sign that she no longer belonged in that world. Today, Curry lives a slower but peaceful life in Montana with her partnerMatthew Rhode.
